Manchester City
Manchester City and Premier League Both Claim Victory After Ruling on Associated Party Transactions (APT) Released
The Premier League and Manchester City both claimed victory after an arbitration tribunal’s ruling over associated party transactions (APT) was made public. The decision comes at a crucial time, as the Premier League continues to face questions over its financial governance, while Manchester City faces separate charges for breaches of financial rules.
What Are Associated Party Transactions (APT)?
Associated party transactions (APT) refer to commercial agreements between football clubs and entities linked to their ownership groups. These transactions are heavily regulated in the Premier League to maintain competitive balance and ensure transparency. The APT rules have been under scrutiny, especially after Newcastle United’s acquisition by Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund, and Manchester City’s ownership by Sheikh Mansour of the United Arab Emirates.
Arbitration Ruling on APT: A Mixed Outcome for Both Parties
In this arbitration case, Manchester City challenged the Premier League’s APT rules, arguing that they were anti-competitive and violated UK competition law. The Premier League, however, defended the APT system as essential to upholding fairness and financial sustainability within the league.
Both parties emerged with partial victories. The tribunal upheld the need for the APT system, rejecting most of Manchester City’s challenges, but also ruled that certain aspects of the APT rules were unlawful. Specifically, the panel found that the rules excluded shareholder loans, a point of contention for Manchester City.
Premier League’s Stance: APT Rules Are Necessary for Financial Integrity
The Premier League argued that the APT rules are crucial for maintaining financial balance among its clubs. According to the league, these rules ensure the effectiveness of the Profitability and Sustainability Rules (PSR), which aim to prevent clubs from overspending and jeopardizing their financial stability. The arbitration panel agreed with this stance, finding that the APT rules are necessary to achieve these objectives and protect the integrity of the competition.
Manchester City’s Victory: Shareholder Loans Exemption Deemed Unlawful
Manchester City’s key victory came with the tribunal’s decision that the exclusion of shareholder loans from APT regulations was unlawful. This ruling could have significant repercussions for other clubs, such as Arsenal, Leicester City, and Brighton, which have benefited from favorable shareholder loan terms. If the APT rules are adjusted to include shareholder loans, it could complicate financial calculations and sustainability efforts across the Premier League.
Potential Implications for Other Premier League Clubs
The arbitration panel’s ruling may have broader implications across the Premier League. Several clubs, including Arsenal and Brighton, hold significant loan debt to their owners, and any changes to the APT rules regarding shareholder loans could impact their financial calculations and long-term sustainability.
The Premier League has committed to revising its APT rules and removing the unlawful shareholder loan exemption. These amendments could lead to a more transparent and balanced financial playing field, but they would require the approval of at least 14 out of the 20 Premier League clubs.
Manchester City’s Financial Case Continues
While this ruling has provided some clarity on the APT issue, Manchester City is still embroiled in another legal battle. The club faces allegations of over 115 breaches of the Premier League’s financial rules between 2009 and 2018. This case is separate from the APT ruling and could carry severe consequences depending on the outcome.
Conclusion: The Future of Financial Fair Play in the Premier League
The ruling on associated party transactions brings both victories and challenges for Manchester City and the Premier League. While the APT rules remain mostly intact, the tribunal’s decision regarding shareholder loans could reshape the financial landscape of the league. As the Premier League works to revise its financial regulations, this case will continue to influence discussions on fair play, transparency, and sustainability across English football.
This ruling is separate from Manchester City’s other legal battle over alleged financial rule breaches, ensuring that the club’s financial situation will remain under scrutiny for the foreseeable future.
Manchester City
Ruben Amorim Denies Discipline Issues After Rashford and Garnacho Miss Manchester Derby
Manchester United manager Ruben Amorim addressed the surprise omissions of Marcus Rashford and Alejandro Garnacho from the squad for Sunday’s Manchester derby, insisting there were no disciplinary reasons behind the decision.
Fans were left puzzled when neither forward was included in the 20-man roster for the high-stakes clash against Manchester City. However, Amorim’s gamble paid off as United secured a dramatic 2-1 victory thanks to two late goals. Rashford had featured for 56 minutes in United’s 2-1 Europa League comeback win over Viktoria Plzen on Thursday, while Garnacho was introduced as a late substitute in that game.
Rather than joining their teammates at the Etihad Stadium on Sunday, both players trained separately at United’s Carrington base during the match.
Speaking after the derby victory, Amorim dismissed speculation of disciplinary actions but hinted at the high standards he demands from his players at Old Trafford.
“It’s not a disciplinary matter,” he said firmly. “Next week brings new opportunities, a new game, and they’ll be fighting for their spots again.
“For me, everything matters: how you perform in training, how you play during matches, the way you present yourself, your diet, and how you connect with and push your teammates.
“This is a critical time for the club, and we are trying to raise the bar. People in our organization are losing their jobs, so we need to hold ourselves to the highest standards. Everyone must earn their place in this team.”
Amorim emphasized that the team’s ability to succeed without key players demonstrated the collective strength of the squad.
“Today, we showed that we can leave out anyone and still win if we play as a team,” he added.
The Portuguese coach, who previously managed Sporting Lisbon, also made it clear that he would have openly addressed any disciplinary issues if they had occurred.
“There are small things we need to adjust,” Amorim explained. “But this wasn’t a disciplinary situation. It’s about performance in training and matches, and I have to make decisions.
“Even Jonny Evans, who is crucial to our team, stayed home despite doing everything right. If there was a disciplinary issue, I would say it openly, but that’s not the case here. Rashford and Garnacho trained hard today, and it’s a new week with new opportunities.”
Reports had linked Garnacho’s absence to rumors of leaked team information, but a club source told the PA news agency that this was not the case.
When asked about the alleged leaks, Amorim acknowledged the challenge of maintaining confidentiality in modern football.
“I’m aware of the rumors, but it’s difficult to control these things,” he said. “With so many people in the club and players talking to agents or friends, leaks are almost impossible to stop.
“It’s not ideal, but we’ll move on and focus on preparing for the next match.”
Manchester City
Manchester City Braces for a Rare Derby Challenge Against Rivals United
In the midst of a concerning slump, Pep Guardiola faces another sleepless night as Manchester City prepare to host their cross-town rivals, Manchester United, in what promises to be a fiery derby. The clash, scheduled for 5:30 AM on Monday (NZT), marks the first Premier League meeting between Guardiola and Ruben Amorim, United’s recently appointed manager.
For the first time in years, City enter the derby under a heavier cloud of turmoil than their local rivals. A string of poor performances has seen the reigning champions win just once in their last 10 matches across all competitions. Last week’s 2-0 defeat to Juventus in the Champions League was City’s seventh loss during this stretch—a stunning fall from grace for a team that has claimed six of the past seven Premier League titles, including the last four consecutively.
United, on the other hand, have also struggled to find consistency under Amorim, who replaced Erik ten Hag last month. The Red Devils have managed only three wins in Amorim’s first six games at the helm, but the Portuguese coach already holds a psychological edge over Guardiola. In November, Amorim’s Sporting CP humiliated City with a 4-1 victory in the Champions League, thanks to Viktor Gyökeres’ stunning hat-trick.
That defeat exposed major defensive frailties in Guardiola’s side and came just days before Amorim officially took charge at Old Trafford. Now, Guardiola will be eager for revenge at the Etihad Stadium. However, whether his injury-hit squad, low on confidence, can secure a vital victory remains uncertain.
Guardiola Under Pressure
City’s ongoing struggles have clearly taken a toll on Guardiola. Speaking before the Juventus defeat, the Spaniard admitted his mental state was “ugly” and revealed that his sleep and appetite had been affected by the team’s poor run of form. Despite recently signing a two-year contract extension, Guardiola is under significant pressure, with City sitting fourth in the league—eight points behind leaders Liverpool, who also hold a game in hand.
“In our jobs, we always aim to do our best, and when that doesn’t happen, it’s uncomfortable,” Guardiola admitted on Friday. “I’m always thinking about the next game, what I need to do, and how to improve. That’s just how it is.”
City’s defensive woes add to Guardiola’s concerns, with potentially only three fit defenders available for the derby. The manager will be desperate to restore momentum, as another loss to Amorim would deepen City’s woes.
United’s Ongoing Rebuilding Effort
While City’s struggles have been shocking, United’s journey under Amorim has been far from smooth. The Red Devils sit a dismal 13th in the league after back-to-back losses to Arsenal and Nottingham Forest. A nervy 2-1 win over Viktoria Plzen in the Europa League on Friday highlighted their ongoing issues, with the team still searching for rhythm and consistency.
Amorim, however, is focused on addressing United’s own problems rather than dwelling on City’s form. “We are up against a great opponent,” the 39-year-old said. “I’m focused on fixing our issues and preparing the team to win the game.”
Despite City’s slump, Amorim believes they remain a formidable force. “Great teams can bounce back at any moment,” he said. “City have a deep understanding of the game and the confidence to turn things around, even in challenging periods.”
As both sides battle their respective challenges, the stage is set for an unpredictable derby, with pride and crucial points on the line.
Manchester City
Ilkay Gundogan and Pep Guardiola Reflect on Manchester City’s Champions League Defeat to Juventus
Ilkay Gundogan and Pep Guardiola offered contrasting views following Manchester City’s 2-0 loss to Juventus in the UEFA Champions League. While Gundogan called for greater sacrifices and focus from his teammates, Guardiola took a more optimistic stance, commending the team’s overall performance despite the unfavorable outcome.
Diverging Perspectives on the Defeat
Goals from Dusan Vlahovic and Weston McKennie handed City their seventh defeat in 10 matches across all competitions, leaving the club’s Champions League aspirations in jeopardy. Post-match, Gundogan provided a candid assessment of the team’s struggles.
“It’s very disappointing,” Gundogan told TNT Sports. “We had chances, but at the moment, every attack we face feels extremely dangerous. Sometimes we’re careless in duels and overcomplicate situations.
“We lose possession in transition, giving them counter-attacks and forcing us to chase back 50 or 60 meters. Our strength lies in possession, maintaining control, and avoiding unnecessary losses.”
Gundogan emphasized the psychological aspect of the team’s issues, noting, “It’s a mental challenge. When we lose the ball or a duel, our rhythm drops significantly. Opponents don’t need to do much to disrupt us, and this has a big impact. We need to focus on the basics to regain confidence.
“We’re in a critical moment, making poor decisions. We know what’s going wrong, but it’s about finding the right switch to change our fortunes. It’s not far off, but every player must question how they can contribute more to the team.”
Guardiola’s Optimistic Outlook
In contrast, Guardiola expressed pride in his team’s effort, asserting that the result did not reflect their quality of play.
“We played really, really well,” Guardiola remarked. “We missed the final action and conceded a couple of goals, but I’m proud of the players. They gave everything on the pitch. Hopefully, we can turn the results around. It’s challenging in the Champions League, but our performance was excellent.”
When asked about Gundogan’s suggestion that the team overcomplicates their play, Guardiola disagreed. “No, today we kept things simple and executed well. Previously, maybe that was an issue, but not today. We maintained possession and created opportunities. Against Italian teams that defend deep and compact, it’s always a challenge.
“We stayed true to our identity. We have two more games in the group stage and need one win. Matches against Feyenoord and Inter caused us problems, but when we overcome this, we will appreciate our past successes even more.”
Upcoming Challenges
Manchester City’s next Champions League test is a trip to Paris Saint-Germain, followed by a home match against Club Brugge to conclude the group stage. In domestic competition, City faces a critical Premier League clash against rivals Manchester United on Sunday, where they will look to regain momentum
-
Business3 weeks ago
Thailand to Finalise Free Trade Agreement with EFTA by January 2024
-
Visa & Immigration3 months ago
How to Register a Business in Thailand for Foreigners in 2024
-
News3 weeks ago
M81 Motorway Opens Free for New Year Travel in Thailand
-
News2 weeks ago
Thailand and Vietnam Rising to New Heights of Enduring Friendship
-
Business3 weeks ago
Thai Airways Secures 44 Billion Baht to Propel Post-Rehabilitation Future
-
Business10 months ago
Economic advisory board confirms sluggish growth in 2023 and slowing economy coming into 2024. Since 2019, Thailand’s economy
-
News2 weeks ago
ASEAN Ministers to Discuss Myanmar Crisis at Meeting in Thailand
-
Liverpool2 months ago
England Interim Manager Carsley to Include Liverpool and Newcastle Stars Amid ‘Major Injury Crisis’ with ‘Six Doubts’